Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Episodes 4 & 5: We Love a Halloween Episode

Of course we'd come around on the series when it had its Halloween episode! We come in excited to discuss Imogen throwing a rager, how sweet all the love interests are (for now...), everybody pairing off, and how the show flipped our views on Karen/Kelly. We also dig into some difficult reveals about Tabby and Mouse, the show incorporating Tabby's film language better, the devastating Ouija board scene and the hilarious Monster Mash death.

Episode 106 content warnings: kidnapping, pedophilia, drug use, marijuana, murder, gore, suicide, self harm, abuse, sexual abuse, rape, policing, gaslighting, mental health, manipulation

Brenton's detective club theme is "80s retrowave" by Eugene Barduja

Follow us on bluesky @dead-ends.bsky.social

Send your podcast or show questions to our inbox at deadendspcast@gmail.com.

Find all of Emily's links here: https://linktr.ee/emilypyle
Find all of Brenton's here: https://linktr.ee/brentonpyle

Chapters

• 0:00 Content Warning
• 0:26 Positive thoughts on the episodes!
• 2:59 Episode 4 recap
• 21:08 Episode 4 discussion
• 45:43 Episode 5: Toilet Paper-ing & general pranks
• 52:43 Episode 5 recap
• 1:06:00 Episode 5 discussion
• 1:20:18 Brenton's Detective Club
• 1:29:16 More positive on the show
• 1:30:04 Plugs